SHOCKING! Malaysian Illegal Wildlife Trade Exposé

Posted by Unknown On Thursday, December 24, 2009 26 comments


First one jet engine went missing followed by another. Then NST reported that the parts of the jet-fighter were also missing. Now, we have consignments of live animals and body parts worth millions of ringgit that slipped through Malaysia undetected as reported in The Star.

Interpol estimates that illegal wildlife trade worldwide is worth US$10bil (RM35bil) to US$20bil (RM70bil) a year. It is third behind only the illegal drug and arms trades. In fact, it is the second biggest threat to species survival after habitat destruction.



Many people intentionally participate in the illegal wildlife trade for material gain. Some illegal items, such as ivory trinkets and turtle shells, can easily be purchased in stores or on the Internet by unsuspecting customers. Worse still, wildlife and wildlife products may be legally sold at tourist destinations, but bringing these items home with you may be illegal or require special Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) permits.


Many Malaysians DO NOT KNOW that some Malaysians are making waves in the shadowy world of illegal wildlife trade. The shocking thing is that foreigners know more than us about this. By next week, all and sundry will know about it when the January 2010 issue of National Geographic hits the stands on December 29th, 2009!

That issue will have The Kingpin - An exposé of the world's most notorious wildlife dealer, his special government friend, and his ambitious new plan written by Brian Christy. An advanced web edition was released on December 15th 2009 at National Geographic official web site. It is a very long story that took THREE YEARS of research. Believe me - the intricate details of illegal wildlife trade and its ties with ONE MALAYSIAN man and his cronies will blow your brains to smithereens. It is an awfully long article but one that YOU HAVE TO READ!!! I cannot post on it because of copyright and embargo reasons.

Brian Christy is a very highly qualified conservationist with degrees who has written many books that have received rave reviews. Known as the Lizard King, Brian Christy is a graduate of Pennsylvania State University, Cornell's FALCON Japanese Program, the University of Michigan Law School, and was awarded a Fulbright Scholarship to Tokyo University Law School. He passed the CPA and bar exams and worked as a lawyer in Washington, DC, including in the Executive Office of the President. As a lawyer he advised on such topics as relations with Libya, U.S.-Japan supercomputer trade, and the sale of light-water nuclear reactors to North Korea.

His official website has archived many newspaper articles on the whole issue. Please check the following articles for a better understanding of the intricate details of the illegal wildlife trade in Malaysia. While doing research for this post, I discovered that Starprobe conducted a lot of investigations on this issue, in particular by award-winning journalist Hilary Chiew. Brian Christy has painstakingly compiled these in chronological order.

Link 1 on Penang that contains four articles from MSM
Link 2 on Penang that contains another six articles from MSM.

This post required lots of reading I and have compiled a brief chronological account of recent developments.

Hilary Chiew of The Star reported on August 10th 2009 a very detailed write up on Illegal animal trading puts Malaysia on the world map for all the wrong reasons which you also HAVE to read. Sorry. The details will blow your mind!

On the same day, The Star also carried a story on Malaysia is a hub for a multi-billion-ringgit global trade in illegal wildlife. It named the guy and featured his photograph in the report.

On August 11th, Yeng Ai Chun of The Star reported:

The Wildlife and National Parks Department (Perhilitan) is keeping mum over allegations that Malaysia is a major wildlife trafficking centre.

Perhilitan director-general Datuk Abdul Rasid Samsudin had replied: “it is an old story” when asked to comment on the Starprobe story yesterday alleging that illegal trading in wildlife had put Malaysia on the world map for the wrong reasons.

When pointed out that the problem was still going on and the number of cases were getting higher, Abdul Rasid said: “I cannot comment on that.”
On August 12th, Hilary Chiew wrote on Tell us about the tigers, says exco man.

On August 13th, The Star featured an article on Ministry to review Wong’s special permits.

On August 15th 2009 a group of Malaysian wildlife organizations and two parliament MPs filed a complaint with the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) calling for investigation into"irregularities” in the enforcement of wildlife trade in Malaysia."

The same day
, Hilary Chiew wrote an article on Deputy D-G: Someone had to take care of Wong’s animals. Hilary reported:

Lawyer and ROAR president R. Surendran said Wong’s special permits covered among others two cougars which were later declared to have died.

“Did Misliah check whether those animals were dead? Or could they have been smuggled out?” he asked.

Misliah, when asked whether she had seen the carcasses, said she had relied on her staff to “check and report back to her.”

On Wong’s tigers, she said he had a special permit to keep two female tigers that he acquired from Japan and the cats had mated with tigers owned by Sunway Lagoon theme park in Selangor.

Brian Christy said in his blog:

It is interesting that Anson Wong should admit in US Court (and more recently to The Star) that he committed the years of massive scale illegal trafficking of which he was accused and yet the official in charge of Perhilitan Penang during this same period should deny any responsibility and subsequently be promoted to Perhilitan’s national office.
On 21st August, Joshua Fong in reported in The Star:

A group of non-governmental organisations has lodged a police report against convicted wildlife smuggler Anson Wong, the Department of Wildlife and National Parks (Perhilitan) and the Customs Department.

Speaking to reporters after lodging the report at the Brickfields Police Station, Malaysian Animal Rights Society president R. Surendran said:

“The reason we are lodging the police report is because, over the years Perhilitan has failed to take any action against Wong for smuggling and has even given him special permits to catch and keep animals.

“We know that one of the modus operandi of wildlife traffickers is to get permits to keep animals and later declare them dead, when in actual fact they have been smuggled out of the country,” he said.

Outraged? Wait. Let me show you another report:

Joseph Kaos Jr of The Malay Mail reported on June 11th 2009:

WILDLIFE poachers and traffickers may not have it easy soon - if the relentless campaign by the Wildlife and National Parks Department (Perhilitan) and local environmental groups to amend the Wildlife Act 1972 is successful.

The act has received a lot of criticism especially from animal conservation groups for its rather mild punishment and penalties to deter wildlife offenders.

Yesterday, an Indonesian man was fined a mere RM2,000 by the Magistrate court for attempting to smuggle 10 murai batu birds (Common Shama) out of the country last Saturday. The bird can fetch at least RM3,000 in the open market.

If all this has NOT shocked you yet, let me leave you with this link to an article called Endangered creatures for sale - Illegal animal trade reaps billions yearly written by CHARLES SEABROOK of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution where the following was reported:



One of the world's most notorious wildlife smugglers, Keng Liang "Anson" Wong, 44 -- released last month from a federal prison in California after serving six years -- used this method. From his private zoo in Malaysia, he shipped thousands of rare and endangered creatures, mostly reptiles, to collectors in the United States, Japan and Europe.

To fool airport customs and wildlife inspectors, he bound the rare animals with tape so they couldn't move and stuffed them in burlap bags stapled to the bottom of shipping crates. Many died from the harsh shipping conditions, but Wong stood to profit as long as some survived.

In Miami, Stinebaugh's boss, Vicky Vina, says that on a good day, inspectors there are able to peek inside about three in every 10 shipments.

"We get awfully busy," she says. "We often get 60 to 70 wildlife shipments through here in one day."

Scores of animals -- mostly reptiles -- were smuggled through Miami by Chye, Wong and others.
I do not know about you but I am thoroughly ashamed that our country has reached the pits when it comes to legislation and enforcement not just in ONE area but so many areas.

Our resources are dwindling, some going up in smoke while others vanishing into thin air. Now, even our natural resource of wildlife - Nature's gift to us is being taken from right under our noses.

People, what are we going to do?




26 comments to SHOCKING! Malaysian Illegal Wildlife Trade Exposé

  1. says:

    k a l a m b o n g Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!

  1. says:

    stephen Been following the exploits of Anson Wong for a while now in the US media and Nat Geo.This idiot leads a charmed life.Its amazing how he gets away with brazen animal smuggling on a grand scale with impunity.

    Criminals,the likes of anson wong know the system and what buttons to push.A lot,I guess,has to do with officers so caught up in the vicious cycle of corruption that to cut the umbilical cord would result in a lot of heads rolling and open a pandora's box.

    When you have low wages,a culture of corruption,lack of pride in your work ,higher ups "leading by example"and the allure of easy money, the cycle will never stop.

    The illegal pirate dvd trade in penang is another example.Shops are still selling in full view unmolested!Makes you wonder how much "insurance" they are paying!

  1. says:

    Unknown Dear Kalambong

    Thanks! Here's wishing you a Merry Christmas and Prosperous New Year too!

    Warmest wishes

  1. says:

    Unknown Dear Stephen

    Exactly! Thank you so much for your terse and accurate summary of why crime is on the increase. The spillover of the profits from such illegal activities surely benefits certain quarters leading to a Catch 22 situation.

    When will the vicious cycle end? It has to begin with strict legislation and even stricer enforcement.

    Take care and have a blessed festive season.

  1. says:

    nick Sis,

    I'm more than shocked, I'm livid! This is worse than the missing jet engine! This is inhumane! This is not done by human being but creatures from hell (it doesn't matter if they wore scarf and pint size... kecil2 cili padi is apt cos evil can come is small packages with it's small moral values and even smaller principal and the tiniest of brain).

    They may escape the law of human BUT no one escape the Mightiest of Judges and The harshest of Punisher! Misliah, your day will come and justice will catch you yet! (Anson is nothing without these creatures!).

    Do we need anymore reason to replace UMNO and BN and all it's mutated civil service especially those "Mahathirist" whose faith is "might is right and you're clean as long as you don't get caught and the end justifies the means"? NO! not if you have a shred of humanity left in you, Malaysian!

    Hamba.
    I really wanted to put a swear words here Sis but out of respect to you I refrained.... I'm literally boiling mad.... Curse them All!!!!!

  1. says:

    Hafiz b Shukor This missing, that missing!

    We can only pray that Malaysia does not go missing one day!

    It is already half way down the drain, isn't it?

    Wake up, fellow Malaysians!

  1. says:

    Village Boy This is Malaysia. Everything is possible. Malaysia Boleh!

    Nevertheless, however successful those guilty of injustice and inhumanity may appear right now, they are going against the principles of the universe and against the flow of time. Hence, they are doomed to failure ultimately.

    This is an invariable law of history, isn't it?

    Let us keep pressing forward in high spirits, propelling our noble mission of justice in the direction of victory!

    Merry Christmas & Happy New Year!

  1. says:

    Orang Hutan Perhilitan director-general Datuk Abdul Rasid Samsudin's replies:

    "It is an old story."
    "I cannot comment on that."

    Very smart answers indeed!

    Hahaha, what other answers can you expect from him??

  1. says:

    ndhaniya I had to reread the article because I simply could not believe it! It is disgusting and I hope that everyone I know reads this article too. Thank you for bringing it to our attention!

    It makes me sick to my stomach to think that Malaysian authorities are so blind and indifferent. On top of that, is there anyone influential enough in this country who gives a damn enough to set a good example about anything that matters outside the average perhilitan officers' immediate little world?

    So much needs to be changed in this country, and our hands are going to get dirty if anything is to get done. Where will it start?

  1. says:

    Anonymous All animals have feelings. They too have love, care and affection.
    Hence, they should be treated as humans although they don't have the language to explain their needs and fight for their rights!

  1. says:

    Gemini Well said, ndhaniya! Yes, so much needs to be changed in this country.

    "If we are united, we can get many of the things that we not only desire but which we justly deserve."
    - Dr Martin Luther King Jr

    To all who love Malaysia, please continue to advance with unity as our byword!

    We need CHANGE! We must CHANGE!

  1. says:

    A Arthur Excellent article, a scoop indeed when the NG is only coming out next month. Now Malaysia is getting more and more famous or infamous for all the wrong reasons. And do you believe that the world knows more about illegal trading of wild life products than us? Most of them from the Wild Life Dept, Forestry Dept, Home Ministry and all those Ministries who have a responsibility of looking after our wild habitat are all in cahoots with criminals dealing in this trade. Just that they do not investigate or keep their mouth shut when cash is flowing in freely. Zaid may said it right to equate Malaysia with Zimbabwe and who is the Robert Mugabe of Malaysia...you go figure it

  1. says:

    Anonymous Who is the Robert Mugabe of Malaysia??

    Your guess is as good as mine!!

  1. says:

    nick Wishing you a Merry Christmas and may you receive the best gift of all: love and happiness from your loved ones, family and friends.

    Hamba.

  1. says:

    Anonymous Sick, sick, sick! How could these evil vultures be so cruel? These wild life are not meant to be traded and cadged as pets!

    It still boils down to the lack of enforcement and the political will to act on it. But why would these greedy leaders want to do the right thing when so much $$$ is at stake?

  1. says:

    Anonymous Really a shocking thing to know.. They really good in cover it up from the public.. Shame..

  1. says:

    Anonymous We need CHANGE to stop the rot!

  1. says:

    HarapanNegara Malaysia needs a complete overhaul and hopefully, that will happen in the 13th General Election!

    Lawan tetap lawan!

  1. says:

    Anonymous Apparently, more worms are coming out of the rotten woodwork. None of us is shocked or surprised! This is Malaysia, the Bolehland!

    If you are a crony of any of the BN towkays, or have connections with 'those up there', anything can be fixed as per your wish. Semua boleh diatur!

  1. says:

    Unknown To all my dear readers and commenters,

    My heartfelt appreciation to all who read this post and those who took the time to share their thoughts here.

    It is most unlike me not to respond to each comment and I do apologize for my silence. It is not because I am too busy but the truth of the matter is that - I am truly, deeply saddened after writing this post and thinking far and deep about this issue.

    I worked on this post from after dinner with a few breaks in between till past 4.30a.m. editing and re-editing to read to understand the issue and background. I went through every single link listed here and more that I could not include because of the sheer volume of information.

    And I could not go to sleep in the wee hours of the morning thinking about the sufferings of the animals and reptiles, even the small ones.

    Yes, I am a sentimental person and a die-hard animal lover. I can even mourn the death of my hamster for weeks so you can imagine my deep grief and mourning for those who mercilessly perished to satiate the greed of some.

    What have we become? Are we worse than animals now? Has our society become so inhumane that money has superceded the value of human life, animal life and even the environment? (Don't forget illegal logging and the whole works...)

    Where is man's conscience?

    Where are we heading? What are our children learning and what will happen to our souls, hearts, the next generation...our nation?

    Dear God, hear the cry of our hearts and spirits. Deliver us from the path of destruction paved by the sheer greed of man!

    Bless our nation with capable, honorable and upright leaders that our land can be flowing with milk and honey, prosperity and harmony and all that our resources can provide for us!

  1. says:

    stephen Believe me,i have almost given up on this place.Let me relate this to you,I,like a lot of others, purchased a plot of land on the mainland thinking it would a good investment.The shell company goes belly up,declares bankrupt then the parent company forms another shell company to purchase the land from the bank at one tenth the price and even tried to unlock caveats lodged by owners who have paid almost 100% of the purchase price!

    Many people have lost their life savings and some have even been made bankrupt.I for one have been more fortunate in that i am able to write off the amount (about 300K) but just imagine the amount of money that has been swindled.

    The main fear expressed by the group of aggrieved purchasers is that someone with clout could stop the ongoing investigations of fraud for apparent reasons.

    Thats why I sincerely believe that the situation will never change when corruption is so deep seated and those in power are able to bend the rules to line their pockets.

    I have pulled up all my investments here as putting money in the bank is like seeing your money shrink with the shrinking ringgit.Why do you think the crooks are sending their dirty money overseas via money changers to be parked in other currencies?

    Wither the common folk.

  1. says:

    Anonymous Paula :
    x'mas. wishing you happy new year.

    Paula, you did a mistake again. not all wildlife is sell able in market.

    do you know a species name as Kera Jantan? KJ ? it still alive in rembau。

    antimamak

  1. says:

    Anonymous There is yet another species of monkey in Rembau popularly known as Kongkang Jijik (KJ).

  1. says:

    Unknown Dear Stephen

    Many thanks for sharing your painful experience re the deal. Burdens shared feel lighter...and such trials produce endurance, character and wisdom.

    We see many signs of a failed nation. I believe that the moral decay started in the 1980's and we all are aware of how and why. The pervasive influence of one man can have such long-lasting destructive consequences and it seems as though only a genuine paradigm shift of values and morals via divine intervention can lead us to salvation from destruction.

    As for the rest of common folk like me and many others, we have to wipe away our tears, soften our sighs, pray and simply hope for the best, even when things are getting worse.

    Take care and have a good day!

  1. says:

    Unknown Dear antimamak

    Thanks for swinging by and for your warm greetings!

    Take care and I truly appreciate your wit, support, advice and friendship through the months....

    All the best to you and may your Christmas and New Year be blessed with more than you can ever imagine...

    Warmest wishes

  1. says:

    Unknown Dear Anonymous @ 10.26 a.m.

    Thank you for reading my post and for taking the time to share your comment. Let us continue to keep up the good fight and raise awareness of important issues.

    All the best to you for the coming new year.

    Merry Christmas!

Related Posts with Thumbnails
.